Why this matters
This short chapter is about where geometry came from and how Euclid organised it. The paper asks one-mark and two-mark questions here: define a point, name the number of dimensions of a surface, or explain why some terms are left undefined. It also sets up the words axiom, postulate and theorem that every geometry proof in Classes 9 and 10 uses.
The idea
The word geometry comes from the Greek geo, meaning earth, and metron, meaning measure: geometry began as earth measurement. In Egypt the Nile flooded every year and washed away field boundaries, so surveyors re-measured the land and learned rules for areas. Babylonian clay tablets show tables for areas and the relation between the sides of a right triangle.
India has its own long tradition. The Harappan cities of the Indus valley, around 2500 BC, used baked bricks in the fixed ratio 4 : 2 : 1 and laid out streets at right angles. Later the Sulbasutras (about 800 to 500 BC), which are manuals for building fire altars, give geometrical constructions, and the Baudhayana Sulbasutra states the relation between the diagonal and sides of a rectangle that we now call the Pythagoras theorem.
The Greeks turned these practical rules into a system of reasoning. Thales, around 600 BC, is credited with the first proof of a geometrical statement, and Pythagoras and his school proved many results. Around 300 BC, Euclid of Alexandria collected all known geometry into thirteen books called the Elements, starting from a few definitions and assumptions and deducing everything else by logic. His method is the model for mathematics even today.
Euclid's definitions
Euclid began with definitions, of which these are the first seven:
- A point is that which has no part.
- A line is breadthless length.
- The ends of a line are points.
- A straight line is a line which lies evenly with the points on itself.
- A surface is that which has length and breadth only.
- The edges of a surface are lines.
- A plane surface is a surface which lies evenly with the straight lines on itself.
These definitions use words such as part, breadth and length that are themselves undefined. To avoid an endless chain, modern geometry takes point, line and plane as undefined terms, and describes them only through the axioms that relate them.
Three kinds of statements
An axiom is a basic assumption accepted without proof that applies to all of mathematics, such as the whole is greater than the part. A postulate is a basic assumption accepted without proof that is specific to geometry, such as a straight line can be drawn from any point to any point. A theorem is a statement that is proved by reasoning from definitions, axioms, postulates and earlier theorems. Euclid called his general assumptions common notions; today the words axiom and postulate are often used interchangeably.
| Term | Proved? | Scope | Example |
|---|---|---|---|
| Axiom | no | all mathematics | equals added to equals are equal |
| Postulate | no | geometry | a circle can be drawn with any centre and radius |
| Theorem | yes | derived | two distinct lines cannot share more than one point |
Worked examples
Example 1: Why some terms are undefined
Question: Why are point, line and plane left undefined in geometry? (2 marks)
- Euclid defined a point as that which has no part, but part is itself undefined.
- Defining every word would need still more words without end.
- So a few basic terms are taken as undefined, and their properties are stated by axioms and postulates.
Answer: Point, line and plane are undefined terms because any definition of them would need other undefined words; instead, the axioms describe how they behave.
Example 2: Dimensions
Question: Fill in the table: how many dimensions do a solid, a surface, a line and a point have, and what are the boundaries of each?
- A solid such as a brick has length, breadth and height: three dimensions; its boundaries are surfaces.
- A surface has length and breadth: two dimensions; its boundaries are lines.
- A line has length only: one dimension; its ends are points.
- A point has no dimension.
Answer: Solid 3, surface 2, line 1, point 0; boundaries are surface, line, point respectively.
Example 3: Axiom, postulate or theorem
Question: Classify: (i) Things which are equal to the same thing are equal to one another. (ii) A terminated line can be produced indefinitely. (iii) The sum of the angles of a triangle is 180°.
- (i) is a general truth used everywhere in mathematics, so it is an axiom.
- (ii) is an assumption about lines specifically, so it is a postulate.
- (iii) is proved from the postulates, so it is a theorem.
Answer: (i) axiom, (ii) postulate, (iii) theorem.
Common mistakes
- Saying a point has a small size. A point has position only and no dimension.
- Mixing up axiom and theorem. Axioms are assumed; theorems are proved.
- Crediting Pythagoras alone for the right-triangle relation. It appears earlier in the Baudhayana Sulbasutra and on Babylonian tablets; the Greeks gave the proof.
Try it yourself
- What is the origin of the word geometry?
- State Euclid's definition of a line and say which word in it is undefined.
- Name the Indian text that states the relation between the diagonal and sides of a rectangle.
Answers: 1. Greek geo (earth) and metron (measure), earth measurement. 2. A line is breadthless length; breadth and length are undefined. 3. The Baudhayana Sulbasutra.