Why this matters
Proofs in Mathematics is a reading-and-reasoning chapter rather than a calculation chapter, and the paper tests it with one-mark and two-mark questions: is this sentence a mathematical statement, is it true or false, is this an axiom or a theorem. The vocabulary learnt here (statement, axiom, theorem, conjecture, hypothesis, conclusion) is used in every geometry proof from now to Intermediate.
The idea
A statement is a sentence that is either true or false, but not both at the same time. "The sum of the angles of a triangle is 180°" is a statement (true). "7 is an even number" is a statement (false). Sentences that are not statements include questions ("Is 9 a prime?"), commands ("Solve this equation"), exclamations ("What a big number!") and sentences whose truth depends on opinion or on missing information ("Today is hot", "x + 3 = 7").
A mathematical statement is a statement about mathematical objects such as numbers, shapes or sets, whose truth can be decided by mathematical reasoning. It must be unambiguous: "Some odd numbers are prime" is a clear statement; "Odd numbers are big" is not.
The statement "x + 3 = 7" is called an open sentence because it becomes a statement only when x is given a value; for x = 4 it is true, for x = 5 it is false. Statements about all numbers use words such as every, all, any, for each, and are false if even one exception exists.
An axiom is a statement that is accepted as true without proof and used as a starting point. Examples are Euclid's axioms, such as "things equal to the same thing are equal to one another", and the area axiom "congruent figures have equal areas". A definition is a statement that fixes the exact meaning of a term, such as "a prime is a natural number greater than 1 with exactly two factors". A theorem is a mathematical statement that has been proved using axioms, definitions and previously proved theorems. A conjecture is a statement that is believed to be true because of evidence but has not been proved; Goldbach's conjecture (every even number greater than 2 is the sum of two primes) is still unproved.
The negation of a statement is the statement that says the opposite; the negation of "all triangles are isosceles" is "there is at least one triangle that is not isosceles", not "no triangle is isosceles".
| Term | Meaning |
|---|---|
| Statement | true or false, not both |
| Axiom | accepted without proof |
| Definition | fixes the meaning of a term |
| Theorem | proved from axioms and earlier theorems |
| Conjecture | believed true, not yet proved |
Worked examples
Example 1: Which are statements?
Question: Decide which of these are mathematical statements and give the truth value: (a) The square of every natural number is even. (b) Please draw a circle of radius 3 cm. (c) 15 is a multiple of 5. (d) y is greater than 2.
- (a) is a statement; it is false because 3² = 9 is odd.
- (b) is a command, not a statement.
- (c) is a statement; it is true because 15 = 5 × 3.
- (d) is an open sentence; its truth depends on y, so it is not a statement.
Answer: (a) statement, false; (b) not a statement; (c) statement, true; (d) not a statement.
Example 2: Writing negations
Question: Write the negation of (a) "Every rectangle is a square" and (b) "The number 91 is prime".
- (a) To deny "every", show one exception: "There is a rectangle that is not a square."
- (b) The negation is simply "91 is not prime." This negation is true, because 91 = 7 × 13.
Answer: (a) There exists a rectangle that is not a square. (b) 91 is not prime.
Example 3: Axiom, definition, theorem or conjecture?
Question: Classify: (a) A diameter is a chord through the centre. (b) The angle in a semicircle is a right angle. (c) A straight line may be drawn from any point to any other point. (d) Every even number greater than 2 is the sum of two primes.
- (a) fixes the meaning of the word diameter: a definition.
- (b) was proved in the Circles chapter: a theorem.
- (c) is one of Euclid's postulates, accepted without proof: an axiom.
- (d) is believed but unproved: a conjecture (Goldbach).
Answer: (a) definition, (b) theorem, (c) axiom, (d) conjecture.
Common mistakes
- Calling a false sentence "not a statement". A false statement is still a statement; only sentences with no truth value are excluded.
- Negating "all" with "none". The negation of "all A are B" is "at least one A is not B".
- Confusing an axiom with a theorem. An axiom is assumed; a theorem is proved.
- Treating a checked conjecture as proved. Checking many cases is evidence, not a proof.
Try it yourself
- Is "x + 3 = 7" a mathematical statement? Explain.
- Is "Every prime number greater than 2 is odd" a statement, and is it true?
- Write the negation of "Some students of the class are 15 years old".
Answers: 1. No; it is an open sentence whose truth depends on x. 2. Yes, and it is true, since any even number greater than 2 has the factor 2 and is not prime. 3. "No student of the class is 15 years old."