Class 9 Mathematics · chapter 15: Proofs in Mathematics · lesson 42 of 44

Mathematical statements, axioms and definitions

About 35 minutes

Why this matters

Proofs in Mathematics is a reading-and-reasoning chapter rather than a calculation chapter, and the paper tests it with one-mark and two-mark questions: is this sentence a mathematical statement, is it true or false, is this an axiom or a theorem. The vocabulary learnt here (statement, axiom, theorem, conjecture, hypothesis, conclusion) is used in every geometry proof from now to Intermediate.

The idea

A statement is a sentence that is either true or false, but not both at the same time. "The sum of the angles of a triangle is 180°" is a statement (true). "7 is an even number" is a statement (false). Sentences that are not statements include questions ("Is 9 a prime?"), commands ("Solve this equation"), exclamations ("What a big number!") and sentences whose truth depends on opinion or on missing information ("Today is hot", "x + 3 = 7").

A mathematical statement is a statement about mathematical objects such as numbers, shapes or sets, whose truth can be decided by mathematical reasoning. It must be unambiguous: "Some odd numbers are prime" is a clear statement; "Odd numbers are big" is not.

The statement "x + 3 = 7" is called an open sentence because it becomes a statement only when x is given a value; for x = 4 it is true, for x = 5 it is false. Statements about all numbers use words such as every, all, any, for each, and are false if even one exception exists.

An axiom is a statement that is accepted as true without proof and used as a starting point. Examples are Euclid's axioms, such as "things equal to the same thing are equal to one another", and the area axiom "congruent figures have equal areas". A definition is a statement that fixes the exact meaning of a term, such as "a prime is a natural number greater than 1 with exactly two factors". A theorem is a mathematical statement that has been proved using axioms, definitions and previously proved theorems. A conjecture is a statement that is believed to be true because of evidence but has not been proved; Goldbach's conjecture (every even number greater than 2 is the sum of two primes) is still unproved.

The negation of a statement is the statement that says the opposite; the negation of "all triangles are isosceles" is "there is at least one triangle that is not isosceles", not "no triangle is isosceles".

TermMeaning
Statementtrue or false, not both
Axiomaccepted without proof
Definitionfixes the meaning of a term
Theoremproved from axioms and earlier theorems
Conjecturebelieved true, not yet proved

Worked examples

Example 1: Which are statements?

Question: Decide which of these are mathematical statements and give the truth value: (a) The square of every natural number is even. (b) Please draw a circle of radius 3 cm. (c) 15 is a multiple of 5. (d) y is greater than 2.

  1. (a) is a statement; it is false because 3² = 9 is odd.
  2. (b) is a command, not a statement.
  3. (c) is a statement; it is true because 15 = 5 × 3.
  4. (d) is an open sentence; its truth depends on y, so it is not a statement.

Answer: (a) statement, false; (b) not a statement; (c) statement, true; (d) not a statement.

Example 2: Writing negations

Question: Write the negation of (a) "Every rectangle is a square" and (b) "The number 91 is prime".

  1. (a) To deny "every", show one exception: "There is a rectangle that is not a square."
  2. (b) The negation is simply "91 is not prime." This negation is true, because 91 = 7 × 13.

Answer: (a) There exists a rectangle that is not a square. (b) 91 is not prime.

Example 3: Axiom, definition, theorem or conjecture?

Question: Classify: (a) A diameter is a chord through the centre. (b) The angle in a semicircle is a right angle. (c) A straight line may be drawn from any point to any other point. (d) Every even number greater than 2 is the sum of two primes.

  1. (a) fixes the meaning of the word diameter: a definition.
  2. (b) was proved in the Circles chapter: a theorem.
  3. (c) is one of Euclid's postulates, accepted without proof: an axiom.
  4. (d) is believed but unproved: a conjecture (Goldbach).

Answer: (a) definition, (b) theorem, (c) axiom, (d) conjecture.

Common mistakes

  • Calling a false sentence "not a statement". A false statement is still a statement; only sentences with no truth value are excluded.
  • Negating "all" with "none". The negation of "all A are B" is "at least one A is not B".
  • Confusing an axiom with a theorem. An axiom is assumed; a theorem is proved.
  • Treating a checked conjecture as proved. Checking many cases is evidence, not a proof.

Try it yourself

  1. Is "x + 3 = 7" a mathematical statement? Explain.
  2. Is "Every prime number greater than 2 is odd" a statement, and is it true?
  3. Write the negation of "Some students of the class are 15 years old".

Answers: 1. No; it is an open sentence whose truth depends on x. 2. Yes, and it is true, since any even number greater than 2 has the factor 2 and is not prime. 3. "No student of the class is 15 years old."

Quiz

Five questions built from this lesson. Start at Core; the level adapts to your score.

Flashcards

Turn the key terms of this lesson into cards that come back just before you forget them.