Class 9 Physical Science · chapter 3: Atoms and Molecules · lesson 7 of 12

Laws of chemical combination and Dalton's atomic theory

About 40 minutes

Why this matters

The two laws of chemical combination are the foundation on which the whole of chemistry is built, and they carry a sure two- or three-mark numerical in the Class 9 paper. Dalton's postulates are a standard three-mark question. The same laws are used in Class 10 chemical equations and in Class 11 stoichiometry.

The idea

Ancient Indian and Greek philosophers wondered what matter was made of. The Indian philosopher Maharishi Kanad said that matter can be divided again and again until a stage is reached where the particle cannot be divided further; he called this particle the parmanu. Modern chemistry began when Antoine Lavoisier and Joseph Proust, in the late eighteenth century, measured masses carefully and found two laws.

Law of conservation of mass

Lavoisier found that in every reaction the total mass before the reaction equals the total mass after it. The law of conservation of mass states that mass can neither be created nor destroyed in a chemical reaction. In the NCERT activity, a solution of barium chloride is mixed with a solution of sodium sulphate inside a closed conical flask. A white precipitate of barium sulphate forms, but the mass of the flask stays exactly the same. If a reaction seems to lose mass, a gas has usually escaped, and if it seems to gain mass, something from the air has combined.

Law of constant proportions

Proust found that a pure compound always contains its elements in the same ratio by mass, whatever its source or method of preparation. The law of constant proportions, also called the law of definite proportions, states that in a chemical substance the elements are always present in definite proportions by mass. Water from a Krishna river tap or from a laboratory reaction always has hydrogen and oxygen in the ratio 1:8 by mass. In ammonia, nitrogen and hydrogen are always 14:3 by mass. In carbon dioxide, carbon and oxygen are always 3:8.

CompoundElementsRatio by mass
Water H₂OH : O1 : 8
Ammonia NH₃N : H14 : 3
Carbon dioxide CO₂C : O3 : 8
Magnesium oxide MgOMg : O3 : 2

Dalton's atomic theory

In 1808 John Dalton explained both laws with an atomic theory. His postulates are:

  1. All matter is made of very tiny particles called atoms, which take part in chemical reactions.
  2. Atoms are indivisible particles that cannot be created or destroyed in a chemical reaction.
  3. Atoms of a given element are identical in mass and chemical properties.
  4. Atoms of different elements have different masses and chemical properties.
  5. Atoms combine in the ratio of small whole numbers to form compounds.
  6. The relative number and kinds of atoms are constant in a given compound.

Postulate 2 explains the law of conservation of mass: atoms are only rearranged, so the total mass cannot change. Postulates 5 and 6 explain the law of constant proportions: a compound always has the same kinds of atoms in the same ratio, so the same mass ratio. Later discoveries showed that atoms can be divided into electrons, protons and neutrons, and that isotopes of one element differ in mass, but Dalton's theory is still the starting point of chemistry.

The word atom comes from the Greek a-tomio, meaning not divisible.

Worked examples

Example 1: Checking conservation of mass

Question: 5.3 g of sodium carbonate reacts with 6 g of ethanoic acid to give 2.2 g of carbon dioxide, 0.9 g of water and 8.2 g of sodium ethanoate. Show that the law of conservation of mass holds.

  1. Mass of reactants = 5.3 + 6 = 11.3 g.
  2. Mass of products = 2.2 + 0.9 + 8.2 = 11.3 g.
  3. The two masses are equal.

Answer: Reactants 11.3 g = products 11.3 g, so mass is conserved.

Example 2: Using constant proportions

Question: 3 g of carbon burns in 8 g of oxygen to form 11 g of carbon dioxide. What mass of carbon dioxide forms when 3 g of carbon burns in 50 g of oxygen? Which law is used?

  1. Carbon and oxygen combine in the fixed ratio 3:8 by mass.
  2. 3 g of carbon can combine with only 8 g of oxygen, however much oxygen is supplied.
  3. Carbon dioxide formed = 3 + 8 = 11 g; the remaining 42 g of oxygen stays unreacted.

Answer: 11 g of carbon dioxide; the law of constant proportions.

Example 3: Percentage composition of water

Question: Hydrogen and oxygen combine in the ratio 1:8 by mass to form water. Find the percentage of each element in water.

  1. Total parts by mass = 1 + 8 = 9.
  2. Percentage of hydrogen = (1 ÷ 9) × 100 = 11.1%.
  3. Percentage of oxygen = (8 ÷ 9) × 100 = 88.9%.

Answer: Hydrogen 11.1%, oxygen 88.9%.

Common mistakes

  • Adding the mass of all the oxygen supplied to the product. Only the mass that actually combines, in the fixed ratio, appears in the product.
  • Saying the law of constant proportions means equal masses. It means a fixed ratio, such as 1:8, not 1:1.
  • Forgetting that the barium chloride activity must be done in a closed flask. Open flasks can lose gas and seem to break the law.
  • Writing Dalton's postulates as facts about electrons. Dalton said atoms are indivisible; subatomic particles came later.

Try it yourself

  1. 12 g of magnesium burns completely in 8 g of oxygen. What mass of magnesium oxide forms, and which law are you using?
  2. Nitrogen and hydrogen combine in the ratio 14:3 by mass to form ammonia. How much hydrogen is needed to combine completely with 28 g of nitrogen?
  3. When 10 g of calcium carbonate is heated, 5.6 g of calcium oxide is left. What mass of carbon dioxide escapes?

Answers: 1. 12 + 8 = 20 g of magnesium oxide, by the law of conservation of mass. 2. 28 ÷ 14 = 2, so 2 × 3 = 6 g of hydrogen. 3. 10 − 5.6 = 4.4 g of carbon dioxide.

Quiz

Five questions built from this lesson. Start at Core; the level adapts to your score.

Flashcards

Turn the key terms of this lesson into cards that come back just before you forget them.