Why this matters
Rutherford's gold foil experiment is one of the most important experiments in science and one of the most asked five-mark questions in Class 9. The discoveries of the electron and proton and Thomson's model are quick one- and two-mark questions. This lesson is the base for Bohr's model and for the whole of Class 11 atomic structure.
The idea
Dalton said atoms are indivisible. By the end of the nineteenth century, experiments showed that atoms contain smaller charged particles.
Charged particles in matter
Rub a glass rod with silk, or a comb through dry hair, and it attracts bits of paper. Rubbing produces charge, so atoms must contain charged particles. In 1897 J. J. Thomson, working with electric discharge through gases, discovered the electron. An electron is a negatively charged subatomic particle with a charge of −1 unit and a mass about 1/2000 of the mass of a hydrogen atom, written e⁻. In 1886 E. Goldstein discovered canal rays, positively charged radiations in a gas discharge, which led to the discovery of the proton. A proton is a positively charged subatomic particle with a charge of +1 unit and a mass about 2000 times that of an electron, written p⁺. The mass of a proton is taken as 1 unit. Atoms are electrically neutral, so an atom must contain equal numbers of protons and electrons.
Thomson's model of the atom
In 1898 Thomson proposed the first model. An atom is a sphere of positive charge, and electrons are embedded in it like seeds in a watermelon or like dry fruits in a Christmas pudding. The negative charge of the electrons equals the positive charge of the sphere, so the atom is neutral. This is called the plum pudding model. It explained why atoms are neutral, but it could not explain the results of later experiments.
Rutherford's gold foil experiment
In 1911 Ernest Rutherford wanted to find out where the positive charge and the electrons are placed inside an atom. He bombarded a very thin gold foil, about 1000 atoms thick, with alpha particles. Alpha particles are doubly charged helium ions, He²⁺, with a mass of 4 u, moving at high speed. A screen around the foil glowed wherever an alpha particle struck it. He expected the particles to pass straight through with slight deflections, as Thomson's model predicted. The results surprised him.
| Observation | Conclusion |
|---|---|
| Most alpha particles passed straight through the foil | Most of the space inside the atom is empty |
| Some were deflected by small angles | The positive charge occupies very little space |
| Very few, about 1 in 12000, bounced straight back | All the positive charge and mass of the atom is concentrated in a very small volume |
Rutherford compared the result to firing a 15-inch shell at tissue paper and having it come back. From this he proposed the nuclear model.
- There is a positively charged centre in the atom called the nucleus. Nearly all the mass of the atom is in the nucleus.
- The electrons revolve around the nucleus in circular paths called orbits.
- The size of the nucleus is very small compared with the size of the atom; the radius of the nucleus is about 10⁵ times smaller than the radius of the atom.
Drawback of Rutherford's model
A particle moving in a circular orbit is accelerated, because its direction keeps changing. According to the physics of the time, an accelerated charged particle must radiate energy. A revolving electron would therefore lose energy continuously, its orbit would shrink, and it would spiral into the nucleus in about 10⁻⁸ seconds. Atoms would be unstable, but we know that atoms are stable. Rutherford's model could not explain the stability of the atom. Bohr answered this in 1913.
Worked examples
Example 1: Explaining the gold foil results
Question: Why did most alpha particles pass through the gold foil, while a few bounced back?
- Alpha particles are positively charged and heavy; they are deflected only by a strong positive charge.
- Most of the atom is empty space, so most particles met nothing and went straight through.
- A very few came close to the tiny, dense, positive nucleus and were repelled straight back.
Answer: The atom is mostly empty space with its positive charge and mass concentrated in a very small nucleus.
Example 2: Why gold, and why thin
Question: Why did Rutherford choose a very thin gold foil?
- Gold is highly malleable and can be beaten into a sheet only a few hundred to a thousand atoms thick.
- With a very thin foil, each alpha particle crosses only a few atoms, so the deflections can be traced to single atoms.
- A thick foil would absorb or scatter particles many times and confuse the result.
Answer: Gold can be made extremely thin, letting each particle interact with only a few atoms.
Example 3: Comparing the two models
Question: State two ways in which Rutherford's model differs from Thomson's.
- In Thomson's model the positive charge is spread over the whole atom; in Rutherford's it is concentrated in a tiny nucleus.
- In Thomson's model electrons are embedded in the positive sphere; in Rutherford's they revolve around the nucleus in orbits.
- Thomson's model has no empty space; Rutherford's atom is mostly empty.
Answer: Location of positive charge (spread out versus nucleus) and the position of electrons (embedded versus revolving).
Common mistakes
- Saying alpha particles are electrons. They are helium nuclei, He²⁺, positive and about 7000 times heavier than an electron.
- Writing that Rutherford discovered the electron. Thomson discovered the electron; Rutherford discovered the nucleus.
- Saying most alpha particles bounced back. Most passed straight through; only about 1 in 12000 returned.
- Forgetting the drawback. Rutherford's model cannot explain why the revolving electron does not fall into the nucleus.
Try it yourself
- Name the scientist who discovered the electron and the one whose experiment led to the discovery of the proton.
- Compare the mass of a proton with the mass of an electron.
- If Thomson's model were correct, what would Rutherford have observed with the gold foil?
Answers: 1. J. J. Thomson (electron); E. Goldstein (canal rays leading to the proton). 2. A proton is about 2000 times heavier than an electron. 3. All alpha particles would have passed through with only small deflections, and none would have bounced back, because the positive charge would be spread thinly over the whole atom.